02-001344
In Re: Petition For Rule Amendment - Gateway Services District vs.
*
Status: Closed
Recommended Order on Friday, August 9, 2002.
Recommended Order on Friday, August 9, 2002.
1STATE OF FLORIDA
4DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS
8IN RE: PETITION TO CONTRACT ) Case No.: 02 - 1344
19THE GATEWAY SERVICES )
23DISTRICT, )
25_______________________________)
26REPORT TO THE FLORIDA LAND AND WATER
33ADJUDICATORY COMMISSION
35Pursuant to Sections 190.046(1)(g) and 190.005(1)(d),
41Florida Statutes, and Rule 42 - 1.012, Florida Administrative
50Code, Charles A. Stampelos, Administrative Law Judge,
57conducted a local public hearing on July 16, 2002, at 1:00
68p.m., in Fort My ers, Lee County, Florida, for the purpose of
80taking testimony and public comment and receiving exhibits on
89the Petition of Gateway Services District (Petitioner) to
97contract the Gateway Services District.
102APPEARANCES
103For Gateway Services District (now know n as Gateway
112Services Community Development District):
116Erin McCormick Larrinaga, Esquire
120Fowler, White, Boggs, Banker, P.A.
125501 East Kennedy Boulevard
129Suite 1700
131Tampa, Florida 33602
134STATEMENT OF THE ISSUE
138The sole issue to be addressed is whether the Pet ition to
150contract the Gateway Services District meets the applicable
158criteria set forth in Chapter 190, Florida Statutes, and
167Chapter 42 - 1, Florida Administrative Code.
174PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
176On January 31, 2002, the Petitioner filed the Petition to
186cont ract the Gateway Services District with the Secretary of
196Florida Land and Water Adjudicatory Commission (Commission),
203the City of Fort Myers, Florida, and Lee County, Florida. An
214Addendum to the Petition was filed with the Secretary of the
225Commission on o r about March 25, 2002. A Second Addendum to
237the Petition was filed with the Secretary of the Commission on
248or about July 16, 2002. A Third Addendum to the Petition was
260filed with the Secretary of the Commission on or about July
27125, 2002. A copy of the Petition, including its exhibits, and
282the First, Second, and Third Addenda, was received into
291evidence as Petitioner's Composite Exhibit 9.
297On April 2, 2002, the Secretary of the Commission
306certified that the Petition contained all required elements,
314as d efined in Section 190.005(1)(a), Florida Statutes, and
323forwarded it to the Division of Administrative Hearings for
332the purpose of conducting the local public hearing required
341under Sections 190.046(1)(g) and 190.005(1)(d), Florida
347Statutes.
348The Commission published a Notice of Receipt of Petition
357in the Florida Administrative Weekly on May 17, 2002. A copy
368of the Notice of Receipt of Petition was received into
378evidence as Petitioner's Exhibit 8.
383The local public hearing was scheduled in Fort Myers, Lee
393C ounty, Florida, for Tuesday, July 16, 2002, at 1:00 p.m. The
405Petitioner published notice of the hearing in accordance with
414Sections 190.046(1)(g) and 190.005(1)(d), Florida Statutes.
420The Proof of Publication of the Notice of Local Public Hearing
431was rece ived into evidence as Petitioner's Exhibit 4.
440The land currently within the District is located
448partially within the unincorporated Lee County, and partially
456within the incorporated City of Fort Myers, Florida. All of
466the property proposed for Contractio n from the District is
476located within the City of Fort Myers, Florida.
484Sections 190.046(1)(d)3. and 190.005(1)(c), Florida
489Statutes, provide that the county and each municipality
497containing all or a portion of the lands within the proposed
508District has th e option to hold a public hearing within forty -
521five (45) days of the filing of the petition.
530The City Council of the City of Fort Myers, Florida
540elected to hold such a hearing on March 4, 2002. After the
552public hearing, the City Council adopted a resolut ion in
562support of the contraction of the Gateway Services District.
571A certified copy of the resolution was received into evidence
581as Petitioner's Exhibit 5.
585The Board of County Commissioners of Lee County elected
594to hold a hearing on June 25, 2002. Afte r the public hearing,
607the Board of County of County Commissioners adopted a
616resolution in support of the contraction of the District. A
626certified copy of the resolution was received into evidence as
636Petitioner's Exhibit 6.
639At the local public hearing on July 16, 2002, the
649Petitioner presented the testimony of John Gnagey (Gnagey)
657Principal of The Worthington Group; James P. Ward (Ward) Vice
667President of Operations for Severn Trent Environmental
674Services, Inc., and an expert in special district and communi ty
685development district management, operations, planning and
691finance; Andrew D. Tilton (Tilton), Director of Water Resources
700for Johnson Engineering, Inc., and an expert in civil
709engineering with an emphasis in public infrastructure design,
717permitting, and cost estimation in construction for special
725districts and community development districts; and Carey
732Garland (Garland), an associate with Fishkind and Associates,
740Inc., and an expert in economics and finance, including
749financing and the use of community d evelopment districts and
759special taxing districts. The full names and addresses of
768Petitioner's witnesses are attached to this Report as Exhibit
777A. Petitioner's Exhibits 1 through 9, were received into
786evidence at the hearing. A list of Petitioner's E xhibits in
797this proceeding is attached to this report as Exhibit B.
807No other persons or entities presented any witnesses or
816exhibits. No members of the public provided any comment.
825The one - volume transcript of the local public hearing was
836filed on Augus t 5, 2002, with the Division of Administrative
847Hearings. The original transcript and hearing exhibits are
855transmitted with this Report.
859FINDINGS OF FACT
862Overview
8631. The Petitioner is seeking the adoption of a rule by
874the Commission to contract a communi ty development district
883currently comprised of approximately 5,474 acres located
891within the boundaries of unincorporated Lee County, Florida
899and the incorporated City of Fort Myers, Florida. The name
909for the District, after contraction, will be the Gatewa y
919Services Community Development District. At the time the
927Petition was filed, the District consisted of approximately
9355,324 acres. However, on July 29, 2002, a Rule Amendment
946adopted by the Commission, and filed with the Secretary of
956State became effect ive, expanding the District to
964approximately 5,474 acres.
9682. The Petitioner seeks to contract the District by
977approximately 973 acres. The District, after contraction,
984will encompass approximately 4,501 acres.
9903. All of the property proposed to be c ontracted out of
1002the District is located within the City of Fort Myers,
1012Florida.
10134. The sole purpose of this proceeding was to consider
1023the contraction of the District as proposed by the Petitioner.
1033Summary of Evidence and Testimony
1038A. Whether all statem ents contained within the
1046Petition have been found to be true and correct.
10555. Petitioner's Composite Exhibit 9 was identified for
1063the record as a copy of the Petition and its exhibits as filed
1076with the Commission, dated January 2002; the Addendum to the
1086Petition, dated March 25, 2002; and the Second Addendum to the
1097Petition, dated July 16, 2002; and the Third Addendum to the
1108Petition, dated July 25, 2002.
11136. Ward testified that he had reviewed the contents of
1123the Petition and Exhibits as supplemented a nd amended by the
1134addenda to the Petition. Ward testified that the Petition and
1144exhibits as supplemented and amended by the addenda, are true
1154and correct to the best of his knowledge.
11627. Tilton testified that he had reviewed Exhibits 1, 2,
1172and 3 of the P etition. Exhibit 1 is the metes and bounds
1185legal description and sketch of the existing District
1193boundaries. Exhibit 2 is the legal description and sketch of
1203the contraction parcels. Exhibit 3 is the amended legal
1212description and sketch of the District, after contraction.
12208. Tilton testified that the legal description of the
1229existing CDD boundaries was true and correct, and would be
1239amended by a proposed Rule Amendment filed with the Secretary
1249of State July 9, 2002, and effective July 29, 2002.
12599. Til ton testified that Exhibit 2 truly and accurately
1269depicted the legal description of the property proposed for
1278contraction from the District.
128210. A Third Addendum to the Petition, filed with the
1292Department of Administrative Hearings on July 29, 2002,
1300ident ified a scrivener's error in the proposed Rule Amendment
1310filed on July 9, 2002, and included a legal description and
1321sketch of the land within the District, after the contraction.
1331This legal description and sketch amends and replaces Exhibit
13403 of the Peti tion. This legal description was certified as
1351true and accurate by CES Engineering.
135711. Garland testified that his office had prepared
1365Exhibit 7 to the Petition, the Statement of Estimated
1374Regulatory Costs (SERC). Garland also testified the SERC
1382includ ed with the Petition was true and correct to the best of
1395his knowledge.
139712. Gnagey testified that at the time of the hearing,
1407Worthington Holdings, Inc. was the owner of all of the lands
1418to be contracted out of the District. Gnagey testified that a
1429por tion of the contraction property was under contract for
1439sale. A consent and joinder to the Petition to Contract,
1449executed by the contract purchaser was placed into the record
1459as Exhibit 3.
146213. The Petition does not contain the written consent of
1472the owne rs of all real property to be included in the new
1485District after contraction; nor was there any documentation or
1494other evidence demonstrating that either the District or those
1503giving their written consent to the contraction have control
1512by deed, trust agre ement, contract, or option of one - hundred
1524percent (100%) of the real property to be included in the new
1536District, after contraction. See Conclusion of Law 65.
154414. Based upon the foregoing, the Petition and its
1553exhibits, as amended and supplemented by th e addenda to the
1564Petition, are true and correct.
1569B. Whether the contraction of the District is
1577inconsistent with any applicable element or
1583portion of the State Comprehensive Plan or of
1591the effective local government comprehensive
1596plan.
159715. Ward address ed whether the contraction of the
1606District was inconsistent in any way with the State
1615Comprehensive Plan, Chapter 187, Florida Statutes. Ward also
1623reviewed the contraction of the District, in light of the
1633local government comprehensive plans.
163716. Ward t estified that the District would continue to
1647assist the local government in providing infrastructure
1654services required pursuant to its locally adopted
1661comprehensive plan. Furthermore, since the State
1667Comprehensive Plan requires local governments to provid e
1675infrastructure in accordance with locally adopted
1681comprehensive plans, the District would continue to function
1689and assist in meeting this objective of Chapter 187.
169817. Resolution No. 2002 - 11, adopted by the City Council
1709of the City of Fort Myers, Florid a, was introduced into
1720evidence as Petitioner's Exhibit 5. Pursuant to this
1728Resolution, the City Council made a determination that after
1737the contraction, the District is not inconsistent with
1745applicable elements or portions of the State Comprehensive
1753Plan or the City of Fort Myers local comprehensive plan.
176318. The Florida Department of Community Affairs reviewed
1771the Petition and provided a letter dated April 16, 2002, which
1782was placed into Evidence as Petitioner's Exhibit 7. The
1791letter states that the P etition A "is consistent with the
1802goals, objectives and policies of Lee County's Comprehensive
1810Plan.
181119. Based on the testimony and exhibits in the record,
1821the proposed District will not be inconsistent with any
1830applicable element or portion of the Sta te Comprehensive Plan,
1840the Lee County Comprehensive Plan, or City of Fort Myers
1850Comprehensive Plan.
1852C. Whether the area of land within the district,
1861after contraction, is of sufficient size, is
1868sufficiently compact, and is sufficiently
1873contiguous to be d evelopable as one functional
1881interrelated community.
188320. Testimony on this criterion was provided by Ward and
1893Tilton. The lands that comprise the District, after
1901contraction, will consist of approximately 4,501 acres,
1909located within the borders of unin corporated Lee County, and
1919the incorporated City of Fort Myers.
192521. From a management perspective, the District, after
1933contraction, will continue to be sufficiently sized, compact
1941and contiguous to be developed as a functional interrelated
1950community. Th e property remaining within the District will
1959continue to be amenable to receiving services through a
1968community development district.
197122. From an engineering perspective, the District, after
1979contraction, will still be larger than other community
1987developm ent districts. It is contiguous and relatively
1995compact. The land remaining within the District can be well -
2006served by water management facilities, water and sewer and
2015irrigation, roads lighting, landscaping and parks provided by
2023the District.
202523. From a d evelopment planning perspective, the owner
2034of the property, which will be contracted out of the District,
2045intends to market the contraction property for development as
2054three separate, stand - alone communities. This property will
2063be developed independently from the property remaining within
2071the District. Its utility needs will be serviced by the City
2082of Fort Myers.
208524. From development planning, engineering, and
2091management perspectives, the area of land to be included in
2101the proposed District is of suffici ent size, is sufficiently
2111compact, and is sufficiently contiguous to be developed as a
2121single functionally interrelated community.
2125D. Whether the district, after contraction, is the
2133best alternative available for delivering
2138community development services and facilities to
2144the area that will be served by the contracted
2153district.
215425. The District currently provides certain
2160infrastructure improvements and facilities to the property
2167which will remain in the District.
217326. Currently, no services or facilities are provided by
2182the District to the property to be contracted out of the
2193District. Ward, Tilton, and Garland testified concerning
2200whether the District, as contracted, is the best alternative
2209available for delivering community development services and
2216fac ilities to the area remaining in the District.
222527. Ward testified that since the 1980's, the District
2234has provided and maintained infrastructure which services the
2242existing residents of the District, and is also available to
2252service future residents of th e District. The District is
2262responsible for financing, operating and maintaining this
2269infrastructure. Based upon its historical track record, and
2277its current activities, the District will continue to serve
2286these purposes.
228828. Tilton testified that, from an engineering
2295perspective, the District is an excellent alternative for
2303providing community services and facilities to the property
2311remaining in the District because it provides a higher level
2321of service than would be afforded by Lee County or the City o f
2335Fort Myers. This higher level of service meets the desire of
2346the residents within the District.
235129. Garland testified that, from an economic
2358perspective, the District as contracted, will still consist of
2367approximately 5,799 equivalent residential units . There will
2376be no financial impact to the landowners remaining in the
2386District because neither the capital assessments nor the
2394operations and maintenance assessments will be affected by the
2403contraction. Currently, the contraction parcel is not taking
2411an y of the load for capital assessments or operations and
2422maintenance assessments.
242430. Garland also testified that the contraction property
2432is geographically closer to infrastructure facilities
2438available from the City of Fort Myers, than it is to District
2450f acilities. Therefore, the District is not the best
2459alternative for providing this infrastructure to the
2466contraction property.
246831. From economic, engineering, and special district
2475management perspectives, the District, after contraction, is
2482the best alter native available for delivering community
2490development services and facilities to the area that will
2499continue to be served by the District.
2506E. Whether the community development services and
2513facilities of the district, as contracted, will
2520be incompatible wi th the capacity and uses of
2529existing local and regional community development
2535services and facilities.
253832. The services and facilities which will continue to
2547be provided by the District are not incompatible with uses and
2558existing local and regional facil ities and services. The
2567District's facilities and services within the boundaries, as
2575contracted, will not duplicate any existing regional services
2583or facilities which are provided to the lands within the
2593District by another entity. None of the proposed s ervices or
2604facilities are presently being provided by another entity for
2613the lands to remain within the District.
262033. Ward, Tilton, and Garland testified concerning
2627whether the community development services and facilities of
2635the district, as contracted , would be incompatible with the
2644capacity and uses of existing local and regional community
2653development services and facilities.
265734. Ward testified that the District provides services
2665and facilities which compliment the general purpose local
2673governments services and facilities. For example, the
2680District has constructed drainage facilities. These services
2687address the requirements for infrastructure of the local
2695government. After contraction, the District will continue to
2703provide these infrastructure ser vices.
270835. Tilton testified that the services and facilities
2716provided by the District work very well in concert with the
2727adjacent facilities of the general purpose local government.
2735The roadways, utilities, and water management facilities
2742constructed by the District are integrated into the overall
2751system of the adjacent areas.
275636. From a management perspective and an engineering
2764perspective, the facilities and services to be provided by the
2774District, after the contraction, will not be incompatible with
2783the existing local and regional community development services
2791and facilities.
2793F. Whether the area that will be served by the
2803district, after contraction, is amenable to
2809separate special district government.
281337. As cited previously, from economics, eng ineering,
2821and special district management perspectives, the area of land
2830to be included in the proposed District is of sufficient size,
2841is sufficiently compact, and is sufficiently contiguous to be
2850developed and become a functionally interrelated community .
2858The community to be included in the District, after
2867contraction, will continue to require basic infrastructure
2874systems. A determination was made when the District was
2883formed, that the District could best provide these services.
2892This determination will not change as a result of the
2902contraction.
290338. From engineering, economic and management
2909perspectives, the area that will be served by the amended
2919District is amenable to separate special - district government.
2928G. Other requirements imposed by statute or rule.
293639. Chapter 190, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 42 - 1,
2946Florida Administrative Code, impose specific requirements
2952regarding the Petition and other information to be submitted
2961to the Commission.
2964Elements of the Petition
296840. The Commission has certified that the Petition to
2977Contract the Gateway Services District meets all of the
2986required elements of Section 190.005(1)(a), Florida Statutes.
2993Statement of Estimated Regulatory Costs (SERC)
299941. The SERC contains an estimate of the costs and
3009benefits to all persons directly affected by the proposed rule
3019to contract the District -- the State of Florida and its
3030citizens, the County and its citizens, the City and its
3040citizens, the landowners within the District after
3047contraction, and the Petitioner.
305142. Beyond administrative costs related to rule
3058adoption, the State and its citizens, are not anticipated to
3068incur any costs from contracting the District.
307543. Administrative costs incurred by Lee County and the
3084City of Fort Myers related to this Petition are minim al and
3096should be offset by the filing fees paid by the Petitioner.
310744. Landowners remaining within the District will
3114continue to pay non - ad valorem or special assessments for
3125certain facilities. The contraction of District will have no
3134impact on the leve l of capital assessments or operations and
3145maintenance assessments paid by residents remaining in the
3153District. Benefits to landowners in the District will
3161continue to be a higher level of public services and amenities
3172than might otherwise be available, c onstruction, operation and
3181maintenance of District - sponsored improvements to the area on
3191a timely basis, and a larger share of direct control over
3202community development services and facilities within the area.
321045. Sections 190.046(1)(g) and 190.005(1)(a) , Florida
3216Statutes, require the Petition to include a SERC which meets
3226the requirements of Section 120.541, Florida Statutes. The
3234Petition contains a SERC. It meets the requirements of
3243Section 120.541, Florida Statutes.
3247Other Requirements
324946. Sections 190.046(1)(g) and 190.005(1)(d), Florida
3255Statutes, require the Petitioner to publish notice of the
3264local public hearing in a newspaper of general circulation in
3274Lee County for four consecutive weeks prior to the hearing.
3284The notice was published in The Ne ws - Press, a newspaper of
3297general circulation in Lee County for four consecutive weeks,
3306on June 18, 2002, June 25, 2002, July 2, 2002, and July 9,
33192002. The Affidavit of Publication was placed into evidence
3328as Petitioners Exhibit 4.
3332Lee County Support for Establishment
333747. Pursuant to the requirements of Sections
3344190.046(1)(g) and 190.005(1)(b), Florida Statutes, Petitioner
3350filed a copy of the Petition with the City of Fort Myers and
3363Lee County prior to filing the Petition with the Commission.
337348. As p ermitted by Sections 190.046 and 190.005(1)(c),
3382Florida Statutes, the City Council of the City of Fort Myers
3393held a public hearing on March 4, 2002, to consider the
3404contraction of the Gateway Services District.
341049. At the conclusion of its public hearing on March 4,
34212002, the City Council adopted Resolution 2002 - 11 expressing
3431support for the Commission to promulgate a rule contracting
3440the Gateway Services District.
344450. The City of Fort Myers City Council Resolution
3453specifically found that all six (6) of the statutory factors
3463for evaluating the contraction of community development
3470districts found in Section 190.005(1)(e), Florida Statutes,
3477had been met by the Petitioner in this matter.
348651. As permitted by Sections 190.046 and 190.005(1)(c),
3494Florida Stat utes, the Board of County Commissioners of Lee
3504County held a public hearing on June 25, 2002, to consider the
3516contraction of the Gateway Services District.
352252. At the conclusion of the public hearing on June 25,
35332002, the Board of County Commissioners of Lee County adopted
3543Resolution No.02 - 06 - 43, expressing support for the Commission
3554to promulgate a rule contracting the Gateway Services
3562District.
3563CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
356653. This proceeding is governed by Chapters 120 and 190,
3576Florida Statutes, and Chapter 42 - 1, Florida Administrative
3585Code.
358654. The proceeding was properly noticed pursuant to
3594Section 190.005, Florida Statutes, by publication of an
3602advertisement in a newspaper of general circulation in Lee
3611County once each week for the four (4) consecutive w eeks
3622immediately prior to the hearing.
362755. The Petitioner has met the requirements of Sections
3636190.046(1)(g) and 190.005, Florida Statutes, regarding the
3643submission of the Petition.
364756. The Petitioner bears the burden of establishing that
3656the Petition meets the relevant statutory criteria set forth
3665in Section 190.005(1)(e), Florida Statutes.
367057. All portions of the Petition and other submittals
3679have been completed and filed as required by law.
368858. All statements contained within the Petition as
3696amen ded and supplemented by the Addenda to the Petition, and
3707at the hearing are true and correct.
371459. The contraction of the District is not inconsistent
3723with any applicable element or portion of the State
3732Comprehensive Plan or the effective City of Fort Mye rs
3742Comprehensive Plan.
374460. The area of land within the proposed District is of
3755sufficient size, is sufficiently compact, and is sufficiently
3763contiguous to be developable as one functional interrelated
3771community.
377261. The proposed District is the best al ternative
3781available for delivering community development services and
3788facilities to the area that will be served by the District.
379962. The community development services and facilities of
3807the proposed District will not be incompatible with the
3816capacity an d uses of existing local and regional community
3826development services and facilities.
383063. The area to be served by the proposed District is
3841amenable to separate special district government.
384764. Notwithstanding the above, as found in Finding of
3856Fact B, t he Petition does not contain the written consent of
3868the owners of the real property to be included in the new
3880District, after contraction; nor was there any documentation
3888or other evidence demonstrating that either the District or
3897those giving their writte n consent to the contraction have
3907control by deed, trust agreement, or contract, or option of
3917one - hundred percent (100%) of the real property to be included
3929in the new District, after contraction. Section
3936190.005(1)(a)2., Florida Statutes, requires that a Petition
3943for establishment of a community development district (CDD)
3951contain the written consent of the owners of all of the real
3963property to be included in the proposed CDD, or documentation
3973demonstrating that the Petitioner has control by deed, trust
3982ag reement, contract, or option of one - hundred percent (100%)
3993of the real property to be included in the proposed CDD.
4004Section 190.046(1)(e), Florida Statutes, requires the written
4011consent of all landowners whose land is being deleted through
4021contraction (wh ich has been proven here), but paragraphs (f) -
4032(g) of Section 190.046(1), Florida Statutes, would appear to
4041require the Petitioner to follow all of the requirements
4050specified in Section 190.005, including the "consent"
4057requirement of Section 190.005(1)(a)2. , Florida Statutes.
406365. Nevertheless, Petitioner argues that emphasis should
4070be placed on the word "procedures" in Section 190.046(1)(g),
4079Florida Statutes, and that that does not necessarily include
4088satisfaction of the "consent" requirements of Section
40951 90.005(1)(a)2., Florida Statutes, where there is a request to
4105contract more than 250 acres from a CDD, as here. This
4116interpretation appears to be consistent with the Commission's
4124past practice. See , e.g. , Exhibit 1. See also In Re:
4134Petition to Contract Tampa Palms Open Space and Transportation
4143Community Development District ,
4146Case No. 96 - 4213, 1997 WL 1052656 (DOAH Report January 29,
41581997)(Rule adopted July 31, 1997).
4163RECOMMENDATION
4164Based upon the foregoing F indings of F act and C onclusions
4176of L aw, it i s
4182RECOMMENDED that the Governor and Cabinet, sitting as the
4191Florida Land and Water Adjudicatory Commission, pursuant to
4199Chapters 190 and 120, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 42 - 1,
4210Florida Administrative Code, contract the Gateway Services
4217District as request ed by the Petitioner by formal adoption of
4228the proposed Rule Amendment attached to this Report as Exhibit
4238C.
4239DONE AND ORDERED this 9th day of August, 2002, in
4249Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida.
4253___________________________________
4254CHARLES A. STAMP ELOS
4258Administrative Law Judge
4261Division of Administrative Hearings
4265The DeSoto Building
42681230 Apalachee Parkway
4271Tallahassee, Florida 32399 - 3060
4276(850) 488 - 9675 SUNCOM 278 - 9675
4284Fax Filing (850) 92106847
4288www.doah.state.fl .us
4290Filed with the Clerk of the
4296Division of Administrative Hearings
4300this 9th day of August, 2002.
4306COPIES FURNISHED TO:
4309Erin McCormick Larrinaga. Esquire
4313Fowler, White, Boggs, Banker, P.A.
4318501 East Kennedy Boulevard
4322Suite 1700
4324Tampa , Florida 33602
4327Gregory Munson, Esquire
4330Office of the Governor
4334The Capitol, Room 209
4338Tallahassee, Florida 32399
4341Charles Canady, General Counsel
4345Florida Land and Water
4349Adjudicatory Commission
4351Office of the Governor
4355The Capitol, Room 209
4359Tallahassee, F lorida 32399
4363Donna Arduin, Secretary
4366Florida Land and Water
4370Adjudicatory Commission
4372Office of the Governor
4376The Capitol, Room 2105
4380Tallahassee, Florida 32399
4383Barbara Leighty, Clerk
4386Growth Management and Strategic Planning
4391The Capitol, Room 2105
4395Talla hassee, Florida 32399
4399Exhibit A
4401Petitioners Witnesses at Public Hearing
4406John Gnagey
4408The Worthington Group
441114291 Metro Parkway, Building 1300
4416Fort Myers, Florida 33912
4420James P. Ward
4423Severn Trent Environmental Services, Inc.
4428210 N. University Driv e, Suite 702
4435Coral Gables, Florida 33071
4439Andrew D. Tilton
4442Johnson Engineering, Inc.
44452158 Johnson Street
4448Fort Myers, Florida 33901
4452Carey Garland
4454Fishkind & Associates, Inc.
445811869 High Tech Avenue
4462Orlando, Florida 32817
4465Exhibit B
4467List of Petitioners Exhibits
4471Exhibit Description
4473Exhibit 1: Memorandum from Greg Munson, Staff Attorney
4481for the Florida Land and Water Adjudicatory
4488Commission to Barbara Leighty, Clerk for the
4495Florida Land and Water Adjudicatory
4500Commission, dated March 12, 2002
4505Exhibit 2 : Sketch depicting Gateway Services District
4513Boundaries (Parcels marked A constitute the
4521Contraction Parcels which Petition seeks to
4527have contracted from the Gateway Services
4533District)
4534Exhibit 3: Consent and Joinder to Petition to Contract
4543Gateway Servi ces District, executed by Pulte
4550Home Corporation on July 16, 2002
4556Exhibit 4: News - Press Affidavit of Publication, dated
4565July 9, 2002
4568Exhibit 5: Certified Copy of Resolution No. 2002 - 11,
4578approved by the City Council of the City of
4587Fort Myers on March 4, 2 002
4594Exhibit 6: Certified Copy of Resolution No. 02 - 06 - 43,
4606approved by the Board of County Commissioners
4613of Lee County, Florida on June 25, 2002
4621Exhibit 7: Letter from the Florida Department of
4629Community Affairs to Ms. Donna Arduin,
4635Secretary, Florida Lan d and Water
4641Adjudicatory Commission, dated April 16, 2002
4647Exhibit 8: Notice of Receipt of Petition, published by
4656the Florida Land and Water Adjudicatory
4662Commission in the Florida Administrative
4667Weekly on May 17, 2002
4672Composite
4673Exhibit 9: Petition to Con tract Gateway Services
4681District, dated January, 2002 (includes City
4687of Ft. Myers Comprehensive Plan and Lee
4694County Comprehensive Plan); Addendum to the
4700Petition to Contract Gateway Services
4705District, dated March 25, 2002; Second
4711Addendum to the Petition to Contract Gateway
4718Services District, dated July 16, 2002; and
4725Third Addendum to the Petition to Contract
4732Gateway Services District, dated July 25,
47382002.
4739Exhibit C
4741THE FULL TEXT OF THE PROPOSED RULE AMENDMENT IS:
475042F - 1.002 Boundary.
4754The boundaries of the district are as follows:
4762A tract or parcel of land lying Section 35, Township 44 South,
4774Range 25 East and in Sections 1, 2, 3, 4, 10, 11 and 12,
4788Township 45 South, Range 25 East; Section 31, Township 44
4798South, Range 26 East and in Sections 5, 6, 7, 8, 17, 18 and
481219, Township 45 South, Range 26 East, Lee County, Florida,
4822more particularly described as follows:
4827Beginning at the southwest corner of said Section 35 run N
483800__47' 42" W along the west line of the southwest quarter
4849(SW - 3 ) of said Section fo r 2643.18 feet to the quarter corner
4864on the west line of said section; thence run N 00_ 43' 47" W
4878along the west line of the northwest quarter (NW - 3 ) of said
4892Section for 1361.42 feet; thence run N 35__45' 29" E for
4903947.82 feet; thence run N 56__15' 44" E f or 690.61 feet to the
4917south line of the Colonial Boulevard right - of - way (State Road
4930884) (250 feet wide); thence run S 89__38' 27" E along said
4942south line for 2763.96 feet to an intersection with the west
4953line of the northeast quarter (NE - 1/4) of the north east
4965quarter (NE - 1/4) of said Section; thence run S 02__16' 01" E
4978along said west line for 1,168.38 feet to the southwest corner
4990of said fraction; thence run N 89_ 54' 24" E along the south
5003line of said fraction for 1324.86 feet to the southeast corner
5014of said fraction; thence run S 03__20' 25" E for 1284.37 feet
5026to the quarter corner on the east line of said Section; thence
5038run S 00__01' 59" E along said east line for 2635.65 feet to
5051the northwest corner of said Section 1; thence run N 89__28'
506242" E along the north line of the northwest quarter (NW - 1/4)
5075of said Section 1 for 2,642.98 feet to the quarter corner on
5088said north line; thence run S 89__57' 06" E along the north
5100line of the northeast quarter (NE - 1/4) of said Section 1 for
51132523.38 feet to the north east corner of said Section; thence
5124run N 00__57' 01" W along the west line of said Section 31 for
51382644.12 feet to the quarter corner on said west line; thence
5149run N 00__35' 02" W along said west line of said Section 31
5162for 1705.47 feet to an intersection with the southwesterly
5171line of Immokalee Road (State Road 82) (200 feet wide); thence
5182run S 46__07' 29" E along said southwesterly line for 6215.51
5193feet to an intersection with the south line of said Section
520431; thence continue S 46__07' 29" E along said s outhwesterly
5215line for 1227.27 feet to an intersection with a line common to
5227said Sections 5 and 6; thence continue S 46__07' 29" E along
5239said southwesterly line for 1535.36 feet to a point of
5249curvature; thence run Southeasterly along said southwesterly
5256lin e along the arc of a curve to the left of radius 5824.88
5270feet (delta 18_ 13' 21") (chord bearing S 55__14' 10" E)
5282(chord 1844.76 feet) for 1852.55 feet to a point of tangency;
5293thence continue along said southwesterly line S 64__20' 50" E
5303for 22.21 feet to an intersection with the east line of the
5315west half (W - 1/2) of said Section 5; thence run S 00__06' 33"
5329E along said east line for 2271.81 feet to the quarter corner
5341common to said Sections 5 and 8; thence run S 01__02' 00" E
5354along the east line of the wes t half (W - 1/2) of said Section 8
5370for 3,028.35 feet; thence run N 89__33' 57" E for 605.03 feet;
5383thence run S 01__02' 00" E for 1800.10 feet; thence run S
539589__33' 57" W for 605.03 feet; thence run S 01__02' 00" E for
5408500.03 feet to the quarter corner common to said Sections 8
5419and 17; thence run S 01__00 ' 12" E along the east line of the
5434northwest quarter (NW - 1/4) of said Section 17 for 926.76 feet
5446to an intersection with the northeasterly line of a Florida
5456Power and Light Company substation site as described in deed
5466recorded in Official Record Book 1606 at Page 1286 of the Lee
5478County Records; thence run N 37__57' 04" W along said
5488northeasterly line for 361.70 feet; thence run S 52__02' 56" W
5499along the northwesterly line of said Site for 361.70 feet;
5509thence ru n S 37__57' 04" E along the southwesterly line of
5521said Site for 741.48 feet to an intersection with the
5531northwesterly line of Daniels Road Extension (200 feet wide)
5540as described in deed recorded at Official Record Book 1644 at
5551Page 1739 of the Lee County R ecords; thence run N 68__38' 13"
5564E along said northwesterly line for 64.84 feet to an
5574intersection with said easterly line of said northwest quarter
5583(NW - 1/4) of said Section 17; thence run S 01__00' 12" E along
5597said east line for 1238.52 feet to the southe ast corner of
5609said fraction; thence run S 89__30' 38" W along the south line
5621of said fraction and the north line of the Southwest Florida
5632Regional Airport for 2110.83 feet to an intersection with the
5642southeasterly line of said Daniels Road Extension; thenc e run
5652S 54__00' 05" W through said Sections 17, 18 and 19 along the
5665southeasterly line of a road right - of - way (200 feet wide) for
56797032.17 feet to an intersection with the west line of said
5690Section 19; thence run N 00__55' 36" W along said west line
5702for 1,4 77.45 feet to the northwest corner of said Section;
5714thence run N 00_ 54' 13" W along the west line of the
5727southwest quarter (SW - 1/4) of said Section 18 for 2,643.95
5739feet to the quarter corner on said west line; thence run N 00_
575239' 39" W along the west lin e of the northwest quarter (NW -
57661/4) of said Section 19 for 2,674.35 feet to the northwest
5778corner of said Section; thence run N 00_ 57' 26" W along the
5791west line of the southwest quarter (SW - 1/4) of said Section 7
5804for 2,645.34 feet to the quarter corner com mon to said
5816Sections 7 and 12; thence run S 89_ 55' 12" W along the south
5830line of the northeast quarter (NE - 1/4) of said Section 12 for
58432,524.67 feet to the west line of the east 2,524.14 feet of
5857said northeast quarter (NE - 1/4); thence run N 01_ 05' 33" W
5870along said west line for 2,646.07 feet to the south line of
5883said Section 1; thence run S 89_ 56' 14" W along said south
5896line for 2,663.19 feet to the southwest corner of said
5907Section, passing through the quarter corner on the south line
5917of said Section at 69.26 feet; thence run S 89__03' 50" W
5929along the south line of said Section 2 for 2645.12 feet to the
5942quarter corner on said south line; thence run S 00__08' 50" E
5954line of the northwest quarter (NW - 1/4) of said Section 11 for
59672670.22 feet to the center of said Section; thence run S
597888__33' 56" W along the south line of said northwest quarter
5989(NW - 1/4) for 2745.77 feet to the quarter corner on the west
6002line of said Section 11; thence run S 89__29' 50" W along the
6015south line of the northeast quarter (NE - 1/4) o f said Section
602810 for 2546.16 feet to the center of said Section; thence run
6040N 00__06' 58" W along the west line of said northeast quarter
6052(NE - 1/4) for 2668.79 feet to the quarter corner on the north
6065line of said Section; thence run S 88__57' 32" W along t he
6078south line of said Section 3 for 2649.25 feet to the southwest
6090corner of said Section; thence run S 88_ 54' 32" W along the
6103south line of said Section 4 for 2059.99 feet to an
6114intersection with the southeasterly line of the Six Mile
6123Cypress Acquisition Area; thence run Northeasterly along said
6131southeasterly line the following courses and distances: N
613931__38' 21" E for 261.19 feet; N 01__23' 47" W for 277.78; N
615237__53' 18" E for 246.16 feet; N 18_ 15' 00" E for 91.84 feet;
6166N 56__35' 37" E for 169.92 feet ; N 85__38' 45" E for 379.20
6179feet; N 70__16' 34" E for 105.12 feet; N 06__16' 12" E for
6192108.95 feet; N 89__11' 29" E for 322.80 feet; N 71_ 11' 39" E
6206for 95.05 feet; N 55__29' 43" E for 156.24 feet; S 86__54' 42"
6219E for 285.36 feet; N 55_ 11' 00" E for 58.8 2 feet; N 73__00'
623408" E for 140.00 feet; N 54__05' 49" E for 115.77 feet; N 10_
624834' 05" E for 104.79 feet; N 24__05' 57" E for 100.09 feet; N
626267__22' 01" E for 230.59 feet; S 85__03' 28" E for 211.24
6274feet; N 05__10' 02" E for 54.09 feet; N 27__24' 58" E fo r
6288106.63 feet; N 10__08' 05" E for 139.90 feet; N 44__41' 11" E
6301for 147.83 feet; N 62__35' 02" W for 105.53 feet; N 23__59'
631348" E for 476.74 feet; N 15__42' 08" E for 368.41 feet; N
632620__55' 23" E for 222.23 feet; N 45__09' 19" E for 183.23
6338feet; N 31__07' 36" E for 305.01 feet; N 32__55' 08" E for
6351155.78 feet; N 17__03' 28" E for 110.45 feet; N 26__26' 47" E
6364for 300.81 feet; N 18__42' 17" E for 150.86 feet; N 04__51'
637619" W for 340.19 feet; N 12__09' 34" E for 251.79 feet; N
638927__12' 34" E for 210.15 feet; N 14__53' 31" E for 323.53 feet
6402and N 35__18' 42" E for 275.49 feet to an intersection with
6414the north line of said Section 3; thence run N 88__37' 17" E
6427along said north line for 530.84 feet to an intersection with
6438the westerly line of State Road No. 93 (Int erstate 75) (324
6450feet wide); thence run S 14_ 49' 52" E along said westerly
6462line for 677.99 feet to an intersection with the east line of
6474the northwest quarter (NW - 1/4) of said Section 3; thence run S
648700__49' 04" E along said east line for 1299.77 feet to the
6499northwest corner of the west half (W - 1/2) of the southwest
6511quarter (SW - 1/4) of the northeast quarter (NE - 1/4) of said
6524section; thence run N 88__12' 52" E along the north line of
6536said fraction for 323.06 feet to an intersection with said
6546westerly line o f State Road No. 93; thence run S 14__49' 52" E
6560along said westerly line for 2.67 feet to an intersection with
6571the east line of said fraction ; thence run S 00__37' 05" E
6583along said east line for 650.21 feet to the southeast corner
6594of said fraction; thence run N 88__09' 46" E along the north
6606line of the southeast quarter (SE - 1/4) of said Section 3 for
66192250.18 feet to the quarter corner common to said Sections 2
6630and 3; thence run N 00__47' 03" E along the west line of the
6644northwest quarter (NW - 1/4) of said S ection 2 for 2605.26 feet
6657to the Point of Beginning.
6662Less and except all that part of the right - of - way for State
6677Road No. 93 (Interstate 75) lying within the southeast quarter
6687(SE - 1/4) of Section 3 and within the northeast quarter (NE -
67001/4) of Section 10, T ownship 45 South, Range 25 East, Lee
6712County, Florida, as more particularly described in the
6720petition for this rule. Containing 5,474 5324 acres, more or
6731less.
6732PARCEL " A"
6734A TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND LYING IN SECTION 35 TOWNSHIP 44
6746SOUTH, RANGE 25 EAST, SEC TIONS 1, 2, 11 AND 12, TOWNSHIP 45
6759SOUTH, RANGE 25 EAST; SECTION 31, TOWNSHIP 44 SOUTH, RANGE 26
6770EAST AND IN SECTIONS 5, 6, 7, 8, 17, 18 AND 19, TOWNSHIP 45
6784SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, LEE COUNTY, FLORIDA, MORE PARTICULARLY
6793DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
6796COMMENCING AT THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF SAID SECTION 35 RUN N
680700 _ 47 ' 42 " W ALONG THE WEST LINE OF THE SOUTHWEST QUARTER (SW
68223 ) OF SAID SECTION FOR 2643.18 FEET TO THE QUARTER CORNER ON
6835THE WEST LINE OF SAID SECTION; THENCE RUN N 00 _ 43 ' 47 " W ALONG
6851THE WEST LINE OF THE NORTH WEST QUARTER (NW 3 ) OF SAID SECTION
6865FOR 1361.42 FEET; THENCE RUN N 35 _ 45 ' 29 " E FOR 947.82 FEET;
6880THENCE RUN N 56 _ 15 ' 44 " E FOR 690.61 FEET TO THE SOUTH LINE OF
6897THE COLONIAL BOULEVARD RIGHT - OF - WAY (STATE ROAD 884) (250 FEET
6910WIDE); THENCE RUN S 89 _ 38 ' 27 " E ALO NG SAID SOUTH LINE FOR
6926539.91 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING; THENCE CONTINUE S
693689 _ 38 ' 27 " E ALONG SAID SOUTH LINE FOR 2224.05 FEET TO AN
6951INTERSECTION WITH THE WEST LINE OF THE NORTHEAST QUARTER (NE
69611/4) OF THE NORTHEAST QUARTER (NE 1/4) OF SAID SECTION; TH ENCE
6973RUN S 02 _ 16 ' 01 " E ALONG SAID WEST LINE FOR 1168.38 FEET TO THE
6990SOUTHWEST CORNER OF SAID FRACTION; THENCE RUN N 89 _ 54 ' 24 " E
7004ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID SECTION FOR 1324.86 FEET TO THE
7016SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SAID FRACTION; THENCE RUN S 03 _ 20 ' 25 " E
7030FOR 128 4.37 FEET TO THE QUARTER CORNER ON THE EAST LINE OF
7043SAID SECTION; THENCE RUN S 00 _ 01 ' 59 " E ALONG SAID EAST LINE
7058FOR 2635.65 FEET TO THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF SAID SECTION 1;
7069THENCE RUN N 89 _ 28 ' 42 " E ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF THE NORTHWEST
7085QUARTER (NW 3 ) OF SA ID SECTION 1 FOR 2642.98 FEET TO THE
7099QUARTER CORNER ON SAID NORTH LINE; THENCE RUN S 89 _ 57 ' 06 " E
7114ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF THE NORTHEAST QUARTER (NE 3 ) OF SAID
7127SECTION 1 FOR 2523.38 FEET TO THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF SAID
7138SECTION; THENCE RUN N 00 _ 57 ' 01 " W ALON G THE WEST LINE OF SAID
7155SECTION 31 FOR 2644.12 FEET TO THE QUARTER CORNER ON SAID WEST
7167LINE; THENCE RUN N 00 _ 35 ' 02 " W ALONG SAID WEST LINE OF SAID
7183SECTION 31 FOR 1705.47 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH THE
7193SOUTHWESTERLY LINE OF IMMOKALEE ROAD (STATE ROAD 82) (200 FEET
7203WIDE); THENCE RUN S 46 _ 07 ' 29 " E ALONG SAID SOUTHWESTERLY LINE
7217FOR 6215.51 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH THE SOUTH LINE OF
7228SAID SECTION 31; THENCE CONTINUE S 46 _ 07 ' 29 " E ALONG SAID
7242SOUTHWESTERLY LINE FOR 1227.27 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH A
7252LINE COMMON TO SAID SECTIONS 5 AND 6; THENCE CONTINUE S
726346 _ 07 ' 29 " E ALONG SAID SOUTHWESTERLY LINE FOR 1535.36 FEET TO
7277A POINT OF CURVATURE; THENCE SOUTHEASTERLY ALONG SAID
7285SOUTHWESTERLY LINE ALONG THE ARC OF A CURVE TO THE LEFT OF
7297RADIUS 5824.88 FEET (DELTA 18 _ 13 ' 21 " ) (CHORD BEARING S
731055 _ 14 ' 10 " E) (CHORD 1844.76 FEET) FOR 1852.55 FEET TO A POINT
7325OF TANGENCY; THENCE CONTINUE ALONG SAID SOUTHWESTERLY LINE S
733464 _ 20 ' 50 " E FOR 22.21 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH THE EAST
7349LINE OF THE WEST HALF (W 2 ) OF SAID SECTION 5; T HENCE RUN S
736500 _ 06 ' 33 " E ALONG SAID EAST LINE FOR 2271.81 FEET TO THE
7380QUARTER CORNER COMMON TO SAID SECTIONS 5 AND 8; THENCE RUN S
739201 _ 02 ' 00 " E ALONG THE EAST LINE OF THE WEST HALF (W 2 ) OF SAID
7411SECTION 8 FOR 3028.35 FEET; THENCE RUN N 89 _ 33 ' 57 " E FOR
7426605.03 FEET; THENCE RUN S 01 _ 02 ' 02 " E FOR 1800.10 FEET; THENCE
7441S 89 _ 33 ' 57 " W FOR 605.03 FEET; THENCE RUN S 01 _ 02 ' 00 " E FOR
7461500.03 FEET TO THE QUARTER CORNER COMMON TO SAID SECTIONS 8
7472AND 17; THENCE RUN S 01 _ 00 ' 12 " E ALONG THE EAST LINE OF THE
7489NORTHWEST QUARTER ( NW 3 ) OF SAID SECTION 17 FOR 926.76 FEET TO
7503AN INTERSECTION WITH THE NORTHEASTERLY LINE OF A FLORIDA POWER
7513& LIGHT COMPANY SUBSTATION SITE AS DESCRIBED IN DEED RECORDED
7523IN OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK 1606 AT PAGE 1286, LEE COUNTY RECORDS;
7534THENCE RUN N 37 _ 57 ' 04 " W ALONG SAID NORTHEASTERLY LINE FOR
7548361.70 FEET; THENCE RUN S 52 _ 02 ' 56 " W ALONG THE NORTHWESTERLY
7562LINE OF SAID SITE FOR 361.70 FEET; THENCE RUN S 37 _ 57 ' 04 " E
7578ALONG THE SOUTHWESTERLY LINE OF SAID SITE FOR 741.48 FEET TO
7589AN INTERSECTION WITH THE NORTHWESTERL Y LINE OF DANIELS ROAD
7599EXTENSION (200 FEET WIDE) AS DESCRIBED IN DEED RECORDED IN
7609OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK 1644 AT PAGE 1739, LEE COUNTY RECORDS;
7619THENCE RUN N 68 _ 38 ' 13 " E ALONG SAID NORTHWESTERLY LINE FOR
763364.84 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH SAID EASTERLY LINE O F SAID
7645NORTHWEST QUARTER (NW 3 ) OF SAID SECTION 17; THENCE RUN S
765701 _ 00 ' 12 " E ALONG SAID EAST LINE FOR 1238.52 FEET TO THE
7672SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SAID FRACTION; THENCE RUN S 89 _ 30 ' 38 " W
7686ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID FRACTION AND A NORTH LINE OF THE
7699SOUTHWEST FL ORIDA REGIONAL AIRPORT FOR 2110.83 FEET TO AN
7709INTERSECTION WITH THE SOUTHEASTERLY LINE OF SAID DANIELS ROAD
7718EXTENSION; THENCE RUN S 54 _ 00 ' 05 " W THROUGH SAID SECTIONS 17,
773218, AND 19 ALONG THE SOUTHEASTERLY LINE OF A ROAD RIGHT - OF - WAY
7747(200 FEET WIDE) FOR 70 32.17 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH THE
7759WEST LINE OF SAID SECTION 19; THENCE RUN N 00 _ 55 ' 36 " W ALONG
7775SAID WEST LINE FOR 1477.45 FEET TO THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF
7786SAID SECTION; THENCE RUN N 00 _ 54 ' 13 " W ALONG THE WEST LINE OF
7802THE SOUTHWEST QUARTER (SW 3 ) OF SAI D SECTION 18 FOR 2643.95
7815FEET TO THE QUARTER CORNER OF SAID WEST LINE; THENCE RUN N
782700 _ 39 ' 39 " W ALONG THE WEST LINE OF THE NORTHWEST QUARTER (NW
78423 ) OF SAID SECTION 18 FOR 2647.35 FEET TO THE NORTHWEST CORNER
7855OF SAID SECTION; THENCE RUN N 00 _ 57 ' 26 " W ALONG THE WEST LINE
7871OF THE SOUTHWEST QUARTER (SW 3 ) OF SAID SECTION 7 FOR 2645.34
7884FEET TO THE QUARTER CORNER COMMON TO SAID SECTIONS 7 AND 12;
7896THENCE RUN S 89 _ 55 ' 12 " W ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF THE NORTHEAST
7912QUARTER (NE 3 ) OF SAID SECTION 12 FOR 2524.67 FEET TO TH E WEST
7927LINE OF THE EAST 2524.14 FEET OF SAID NORTHEAST QUARTER (NE
79383 ); THENCE RUN N 01 _ 05 ' 33 " W ALONG SAID WEST LINE FOR 2646.07
7955FEET TO THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID SECTION 1; THENCE RUN S
796789 _ 56 ' 14 " W ALONG SAID SOUTH LINE FOR 2663.19 FEET TO THE
7982SOUTHWEST CORN ER OF SAID SECTION, PASSING THROUGH THE QUARTER
7992CORNER ON THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID SECTION AT 69.26 FEET; THENCE
8004RUN S 89 _ 03 ' 50 " W ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID SECTION 2 FOR
80213096.18 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH THE EASTERLY RIGHT - OF - WAY
8034OF PROPOSED TREELINE BOULEVARD; THENCE ALONG SAID EAST RIGHT -
8044OF - WAY LINE THE FOLLOWING BEARING AND DISTANCES: THENCE ALONG
8055THE ARC OF A CURVE TO THE RIGHT HAVING A RADIUS OF 2625.00
8068FEET (DELTA 29 _ 13 ' 02 " ) (CHORD BEARING S 15 _ 09 ' 16 " W) (CHORD
80861324.12 FEET) FOR 1338.58 FEET TO A POINT OF TANGENCY; THENCE
8097RUN S 29 _ 45 ' 46 " W FOR 618.63 FEET; THENCE ALONG THE ARC OF A
8114CURVE TO THE LEFT HAVING A RADIUS OF 1487.50 FEET (DELTA
812528 _ 50 ' 26 " ) (CHORD BEARING S 15 _ 20 ' 33 " W) (CHORD 740.87 FEET)
8143FOR 748.75 FEET TO A POINT OF TANGENCY; THENCE RUN S 00 _ 55 ' 22 "
8159W FOR 166.10 FEET TO A POINT ON THE SOUTH LINE OF THE
8172NORTHWEST QUARTER OF SECTION 11; THENCE RUN S 88 _ 33 ' 56 " W
8186ALONG SAID LINE FOR 125.11 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH THE
8197WESTERLY RIGHT - OF - WAY OF PROPOSED TREELINE BOULEVARD; THENCE
8208ALONG S AID WEST RIGHT - OF - WAY LINE THE FOLLOWING BEARING AND
8222DISTANCES: THENCE RUN N 00 ° 55 ' 22 " E FOR 171.23 FEET; THENCE
8236ALONG THE ARC OF A CURVE TO THE RIGHT HAVING A RADIUS OF
82491612.50 FEET (DELTA 28 _ 50 ' 26 " ) (CHORD BEARING N 15 _ 20 ' 33 " E)
8267(CHORD 803.13 FEET) FOR 811.67 FEET TO A POINT OF TANGENCY;
8278THENCE N 29 1 45"46' E FOR 618.63 FEET; THENCE ALONG THE ARC OF
8293A CURVE TO THE LEFT HAVING A RADIUS OF 2500.00 FEET (DELTA
830533 _ 36 ' 51 " ) (CHORD BEARING N 12 _ 57 ' 22 " W) (CHORD 1445.75 FEET)
8323FOR 1466.69 FEET TO A POINT OF TANGE NCY; THENCE N 03 _ 51 ' 03 " W
8340FOR 959.31 FEET; THENCE ALONG THE ARC OF A CURVE TO THE RIGHT
8353HAVING A RADIUS OF 2800.06 FEET (DELTA 10 _ 24 ' 15 " ) (CHORD
8367BEARING N 01 _ 21 ' 04 " E) (CHORD 507.76 FEET) FOR 508.45 FEET TO
8382A POINT OF TANGENCY; THENCE N 06 _ 33 ' 12 " E FOR 11 66.54 FEET;
8398THENCE ALONG THE ARC OF A CURVE TO THE LEFT HAVING A RADIUS
8411OF 1000.00 FEET (DELTA 43 _ 02 ' 49 " ) (CHORD BEARING N 14 _ 58 ' 12 "
8429W) (CHORD 733.76 FEET) FOR 751.31 FEET TO A POINT OF TANGENCY;
8441THENCE N 36 _ 29 ' 36 " W FOR 266.36 FEET; THENCE ALONG THE ARC OF
8457A CURVE TO THE RIGHT HAVING A RADIUS OF 2000.00 FEET (DELTA
846937 _ 40 ' 00 " ) (CHORD BEARING N 17 _ 39 ' 36 " W) (CHORD 1291.27 FEET)
8487FOR 1314.81 FEET TO A POINT OF TANGENCY; THENCE N 01 _ 10 ' 24 " E
8503FOR 245.33 FEET; THENCE S 89 _ 25 ' 36 " W LEAVING SAID WEST LINE
8518FOR 11 4.67 FEET TO A POINT ON THE EAST LINE OF TREELINE
8531BOULEVARD (TO BE RE - ALIGNED) AS DESCRIBED IN OFFICIAL RECORD
8542BOOK 1529 BEGINNING AT PAGE 412 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF LEE
8554COUNTY; THENCE N 00 _ 02 ' 17 " W FOR 68.31 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION
8569WITH THE SOUTH LINE O F SECTION 34, TOWNSHIP 44 SOUTH, RANGE 25
8582EAST; THENCE N 01 _ 00 ' 06 " W ALONG SAID EAST LINE OF TREELINE
8597BOULEVARD (TO BE RE - ALIGNED) FOR 2642.68 FEET; THENCE N
860800 _ 58 ' 02 " W ALONG SAID EAST LINE OF TREELINE BOULEVARD (TO BE
8623RE - ALIGNED) FOR 1048.01 FEET TO A PO INT ON A NON - TANGENT CURVE
8639TO THE RIGHT HAVING A RADIUS OF 1050.00 FEET AND TO WHICH
8651POINT A RADIAL LINE BEARS S 47 _ 49 ' 01 " E; SAID POINT ALSO
8666BEING ON THE EAST LINE OF A ROAD RIGHT - OF - WAY AS DESCRIBED IN
8682OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK 2581 BEGINNING AT PAGE 4060 OF THE LEE
8693COUNTY RECORDS; THENCE ALONG THE ARC OF A CURVE TO THE RIGHT
8705HAVING A RADIUS OF 1050.00 FEET (DELTA 41 _ 49 ' 26 " ) (CHORD
8719BEARING N 21 _ 16 ' 16 " E) (CHORD 749.56 FEET) FOR 766.46 FEET TO
8734A POINT OF TANGENCY; THENCE N 00 ° 21 ' 33 " E ALONG SAID EAST LINE
8750FOR 721.50 FEET; THENCE N 45 ° 21 ' 33 " E FOR 42.68 FEET TO THE
8766POINT OF BEGINNING.
8769CONTAINING 4,390 ACRES, MORE OR LESS.
8776SUBJECT TO EASEMENTS, RESTRICTIONS, RESERVATIONS AND RIGHTS -
8784OF - WAY (RECORDED AND UNRECORDED, WRITTEN AND UNWRITTEN)
8793BEARINGS ARE BASED O N THE NORTH LINE OF SECTION 10, TOWNSHIP
880545 SOUTH, RANGE 25 EAST AS BEARING S88 _ 57 ' 32 " W.
8818TOGETHER WITH:
8820DESCRIPTION
8821SECTION 3, TOWNSHIP 45 SOUTH, RANGE 25 EAST
8829LEE COUNTY, FLORIDA
8832PARCEL "B"
8834A TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND LYING IN SECTION 3, TOWNSHIP 45
8846SOU TH, RANGE 25 EAST, LEE COUNTY, FLORIDA WHICH TRACT OR
8857PARCEL IS DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
8862COMMENCING AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF SAID SECTION 3 RUN N
887388 _ 37 ' 17 " E ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF THE NORTHWEST ONE - QUARTER
8889(NW 3 ) OF SAID SECTION 3 FOR 2477.68 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION
8902WITH THE WESTERLY RIGHT - OF - WAY LINE OF INTERSTATE 75 (I - 75)
8917(STATE ROAD NO. 93) (324 FEET WIDE) AND THE POINT OF
8928BEGINNING; THENCE RUN S 14 _ 49 ' 52 " E ALONG SAID WESTERLY RIGHT -
8943OF - WAY LINE FOR 677.94 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH THE EAST
8956LINE O F THE NORTHWEST ONE - QUARTER (NW 3 ) OF SAID SECTION 3;
8971THENCE RUN S 00 _ 49 ' 05 " E ALONG SAID EAST LINE FOR 1299.77 FEET
8987TO THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF THE WEST HALF (W 2 ) OF THE
9000SOUTHWEST QUARTER (SW 3 ) OF THE NORTHEAST QUARTER (NE 3 ) OF
9013SAID SECTION; THENCE RUN N 88 _ 12 ' 52 " E ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF
9029SAID FRACTION FOR 323.06 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH SAID
9039WESTERLY LINE OF STATE ROAD NO. 93; THENCE RUN S 14 _ 49 ' 52 " E
9055ALONG SAID WESTERLY LINE FOR 2.67 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH
9066THE EAST LINE OF SAID FRACTION; THE NCE RUN S 00 _ 37 ' 05 " E ALONG
9083SAID EAST LINE FOR 650.21 FEET TO THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SAID
9095FRACTION; THENCE RUN N 88 _ 09 ' 46 " E ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF
9110THE SOUTHEAST ONE - QUARTER (SE 3 ) OF SAID SECTION 3 FOR 163.88
9124FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH SAID WESTERLY RIGHT - OF - WAY LINE;
9137THENCE RUN S 14 _ 49 ' 52 " E ALONG SAID WESTERLY RIGHT - OF - WAY LINE
9155FOR 1474.99 FEET TO A POINT OF CURVATURE; THENCE RUN SOUTHERLY
9166ALONG AN ARC OF A CURVE TO THE RIGHT OF RADIUS 22800.31 FEET
9179(CHORD BEARING S 13 _ 33 ' 28 " E) (CHORD 1013.23 FEET) (DELTA
919202 _ 32 ' 47 " ) FOR 1013.31 FEET TO A POINT ON A NON - TANGENT LINE;
9210THENCE RUN N 82 _ 23 ' 52 " W FOR 122.32 FEET TO A POINT ON A NON -
9229TANGENT CURVE; THENCE RUN NORTHERLY ALONG AN ARC OF A CURVE TO
9241THE LEFT OF RADIUS 22685.31 FEET (CHORD BEARING N 13 _ 36 ' 38 " W)
9256(CHORD 966.55 FEET) (DELTA 02 _ 26 ' 29 " ) FOR 966.63 FEET TO A
9271POINT OF TANGENCY; THENCE RUN N 14 _ 49 ' 52 " W FOR 542. 01 FEET
9287TO A POINT OF CURVATURE; THENCE RUN NORTHWESTERLY ALONG AN ARC
9298OF A CURVE TO THE LEFT OF RADIUS 250.00 FEET (CHORD BEARING N
931154 _ 04 ' 24 " W) (CHORD 316.30 FEET) (DELTA 78 _ 29 ' 05 " ) FOR 342.45
9329FEET TO A POINT OF TANGENCY; THENCE RUN S 86 _ 41 ' 03 " W FOR
93451133.06 FEET; THENCE RUN N 02 _ 10 ' 37 " W FOR 387.06 FEET; THENCE
9360RUN N 87 _ 40 ' 37 " W FOR 838.00 FEET; THENCE RUN N 01 _ 19 ' 23 " E
9380FOR 243.00 FEET; THENCE RUN S 88 _ 09 ' 46 " W FOR 190.18 FEET TO
9396AN INTERSECTION WITH THE SOUTHEASTERLY LINE OF SIX MILE
9405CYPRESS PRESERVE, AS RECORDED IN OFFICIAL RECORD BOOK 1741 AT
9415PAGE 1241 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF LEE COUNTY, FLORIDA; THENCE
9426RUN THE FOLLOWING FIFTEEN (13) COURSE S ALONG SAID
9435SOUTHEASTERLY LINE;
9437N 15 _ 42 ' 08 " E FOR 184.34 FEET;
9447N 20 _ 55 ' 23 " E FOR 222.23 FEET;
9457N 45 _ 09 ' 19 " E FOR 183.23 FEET;
9467N 31 _ 07 ' 36 " E FOR 305.01 FEET;
9477N 32 _ 55 ' 08 " E FOR 155.78 FEET;
9487N 17 _ 03 ' 28 " E FOR 110.45 FEET;
9497N 26 _ 26 ' 47 " E FOR 300.81 FEET;
9507N 18 _ 4 2 ' 17 " E FOR 150.86 FEET;
9518N 04 _ 51 ' 19 " W FOR 340.19 FEET;
9528N 12 _ 09 ' 34 " E FOR 251.79 FEET;
9538N 27 _ 12 ' 34 " E FOR 210.15 FEET;
9548N 14 _ 53 ' 31 " E FOR 323.53 FEET;
9558N 35 _ 18 ' 42 " E FOR 275.49 FEET TO AN INTERSECTION WITH THE
9573NORTH LINE OF THE NORTHWEST ONE - QUARTER (NW 3 ) O F SAID SECTION
95883; THENCE RUN N 88 _ 37 ' 17 " E ALONG SAID NORTH LINE FOR 530.87
9604FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING.
9610CONTAINING 111.14 ACRES, MORE OR LESS.
9616TOTAL AREA FOR BOTH PARCELS 4,501.14 ACRES, MORE OR LESS.
9627BEARINGS HEREINABOVE MENTIONED ARE BASED ON THE NORTH LINE OF
9637THE NORTHWEST QUARTER (NW 3 ) OF SAID SECTION 3 TO BEAR N
965088 _ 37 ' 17 " W WHICH BEARING IS DERIVED FROM PLANE COORDINATE FOR
9664THE FLORIDA WEST ZONE (1979 ADJUSTMENT).
9670Specific Authority 120.53(1), 190.005, FS.
9675Law Implemented 190.004, 190.005, FS .
9681History - new 5 - 22 - 86 , Amended .
- Date
- Proceedings
- PDF:
- Date: 08/09/2002
- Proceedings: Report to the Florida Land and Water Adjudicatory Commission issued (hearing held July 16, 2002) CASE CLOSED.
- PDF:
- Date: 08/09/2002
- Proceedings: Report cover letter identifying hearing record referred to the Agency sent out.
- PDF:
- Date: 08/05/2002
- Proceedings: Report to the Florida Land and Water Adjudicatory Commission filed.
- Date: 08/05/2002
- Proceedings: Transcript of Proceedings filed.
- PDF:
- Date: 08/05/2002
- Proceedings: Notice of Filing Transcript of Hearing and Proposed Report to the Florida Land and Water Adjudicatory Commission filed.
- PDF:
- Date: 07/29/2002
- Proceedings: Third Addendum to the Petition to Contract Gateway Services District filed by Petitioner
- Date: 07/16/2002
- Proceedings: CASE STATUS: Hearing Held; see case file for applicable time frames.
- PDF:
- Date: 04/25/2002
- Proceedings: Notice of Hearing issued (hearing set for July 16, 2002; 1:00 p.m.; Fort Myers, FL).
Case Information
- Judge:
- CHARLES A. STAMPELOS
- Date Filed:
- 04/03/2002
- Date Assignment:
- 04/08/2002
- Last Docket Entry:
- 10/15/2002
- Location:
- Fort Myers, Florida
- District:
- Middle
- Agency:
- Office of the Governor
Counsels
-
Barbara R. Leighty, Agency Clerk
Address of Record -
Erin Rae McCormick, Esquire
Address of Record